The Noble Scholar, Shaykh Muhammad Amaan al-Jaami (may Allah have mercy upon him) stated:

If the Ash’aree says to you: “Indeed Allah (‘azza wa-jall) does not come down during the last third of the night (to the lowest heavens); rather it is only His command that comes down.” Say to him: “His command comes down from who?.” He will say: “It comes down from Allah.” Say to him: “This is what we wanted.” Therefore, he (the Ash’aree) has established that Allah is above the heavens.

Source: Sharh al-Waasitiyyah

http://masjidnurallah.com/2016/03/23/a-powerful-refutation-of-the-asharees-by-shaykh-muhammad-aman-al-jami-rahimahullaah/

Original Arabic

الشيخ محمد آمان الجامي -رحمه الله – إذا قال لك الأشعري إن الله عز وجل لا ينزل في الثلث الأخير من الليل وإنما ينزل أمره ! فقل له: أمره ينزل من عند من ؟
سيقول لك : من عند الله
فقل له : هذا ما كنا نريد
إذن فقد أثبت أن الله في السماء

[ شرح الواسطية ]

Advertisements